You are staring at a remodel bid, and three lines near the bottom look almost generous. "Lighting allowance: $2,000." "Tile allowance: $3,500." "Appliance allowance: $8,000." They read like budgets you get to spend however you want. They are not. Those are the lines where the contractor stops committing — and where you start absorbing every dollar of risk that follows.

What an allowance actually is

An allowance is a placeholder. The material or fixture has not been chosen yet, so the contractor drops in a round number to keep the bid total looking complete. It fills a hole on the page. Whether it fills the hole in your project is another question entirely.

Example: "Countertop allowance: $4,500" means the contractor budgeted $4,500 for countertop material. If you choose quartz at $65/sq ft and your kitchen has 45 sq ft of counter space, the material cost is $2,925. The remaining $1,575 should come back to you as a credit. But whether it actually does depends entirely on what the contract says.

Some contracts specify that unused allowance funds are credited to the homeowner. Others say nothing — and silence always favors the party holding the checkbook. A third category routes allowance savings into the next change order, which means you never see the money at all. Read the clause. Every dollar of ambiguity is a dollar the contractor controls.

The three allowance traps

Trap 1: The low-ball allowance

A contractor chasing your signature sets allowances below what any real product costs. Consider a "plumbing fixture allowance" of $1,200 for a full bathroom remodel. Sounds reasonable — until you start shopping. A toilet runs $350-$600. A vanity faucet, $180-$400. A shower valve with trim, $300-$700. Add those up. The allowance cannot cover even the mid-range picks, which means a change order lands before the tile goes in.

Red flag: If the sum of all allowances is less than 15% of the total quote on a kitchen or bathroom remodel, the allowances are likely set below market. Compare them to retail prices at a plumbing supply house or tile showroom before you sign.

Trap 2: The installation cost omission

An allowance covers material. Installation labor is supposedly separate. But where, exactly? A "tile allowance: $3,500" might cover the cost of the tile itself and nothing else. Setting labor for floor tile runs $6-$12/sq ft depending on pattern complexity. For a 120 sq ft bathroom floor, that is $720-$1,440 in labor — and it may not appear on a single line of the quote.

Ask specifically: "Does this allowance include installation labor, or is installation a separate line item?" If installation is separate, find the labor line. If there is no labor line for that allowance category, installation cost is unaccounted for and will surface as a change order.

Trap 3: The markup on allowance overages

Say you fall in love with tile that costs $5,200 instead of the $3,500 allowance. Simple math says the overage is $1,700. But the invoice will not say $1,700. It will say $1,700 plus the contractor's standard material markup — often 15-25% — plus tax. Your actual out-of-pocket overage: $2,040-$2,210.

Contractually, this is above board if the agreement specifies markup on materials. The problem is timing. Most homeowners pick finishes without factoring in contractor markup, because the allowance number on the bid never showed the markup either. It was listed at the contractor's buy price, not the homeowner's pay price. You thought you were $1,700 over. You were $2,200 over. That gap compounds across every allowance category in the project.

How to protect yourself

  1. Price your selections before signing. Walk into a showroom or check online pricing for every category that carries an allowance. If the allowance sits below the mid-range retail price of what you actually want, the bid is already over budget — you just have not been invoiced yet.
  2. Ask for a credit clause. The contract should state in writing that unused allowance funds are returned to you as a credit on the next draw or final invoice. No clause, no guarantee.
  3. Ask whether markup applies to overages. If the contractor marks up material purchases, that markup rides on the overage too. Knowing the rate lets you calculate the true cost of an upgrade before you order it — not after the box arrives on site.
  4. Convert allowances to fixed specs. If you already know what tile, fixtures, or appliances you want, ask the contractor to replace the allowance with a fixed line item for that specific product. A fixed line item is a commitment. An allowance is a guess.

Allowances are not evil — ambiguity is

Allowances exist for a legitimate reason: sometimes you need time to choose finishes, and the contractor needs a number to hold the bid together. That is fine. The damage starts when allowances are set low to win the bid, when the credit-back policy is left unwritten, or when overages carry markup nobody mentioned. A well-documented allowance is a planning tool. A vague one is a trapdoor with a price tag you will not see until you are standing in a half-demolished kitchen.

Want to see if your allowances are realistic?

Run a free audit Back to all guides