A brake job on a 2022 Honda CR-V: $1,180 at the dealership, $540 at the independent shop two miles away. Same pads. Same rotors. Same car. The only difference is the name on the building — and $640 still in your pocket or not.

Everyone knows the dealer costs more. Fewer people know how much more, or when the premium actually buys something. For some jobs the dealer markup runs 80-100% above independent pricing. For others — warranty work, recall repairs, certain software calibrations — the dealer is the only rational choice. Knowing which category your repair falls into is the difference between overpaying and making a smart call.

Labor rates: the foundation of every estimate

Every line on a repair bill traces back to one number: the hourly labor rate. This is where the gap begins, and it compounds across every service on the estimate.

  • Dealerships: $150-$250/hr depending on brand and metro area. Luxury brands (BMW, Mercedes, Audi, Lexus) sit at the top of the range. Volume brands (Toyota, Honda, Ford, Chevy) typically fall in the $150-$190/hr range.
  • Independent shops: $90-$150/hr in most markets. Specialists (European-only shops, transmission shops) may reach $140-$170/hr, but general independents average $100-$130/hr.
What that means in practice: A repair booked at 3.0 hours labor costs $450-$750 at a dealer versus $270-$450 at an independent. On that single job, the labor gap is $180-$300. For a major repair booked at 8+ hours, the labor difference alone can exceed $800.

And labor rates only tell half the story. The other half is hiding in the parts column.

Parts markup: the hidden multiplier

Labor rates get the scrutiny. Parts markup gets the margin. The way each type of shop sources and prices components creates a second layer of cost difference that most customers never examine.

  • Dealership parts: OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts at list price. The dealer buys from the manufacturer at wholesale (typically 30-40% below list) and bills you at full list. On a $200 list-price part, the dealer paid $120-$140.
  • Independent parts: OEM, OE-equivalent (same manufacturer, different box), or quality aftermarket parts at 20-40% below dealer list price. The independent buys through parts distributors and can offer the same quality part at $120-$160 instead of the dealer's $200.
Real impact: On a brake job requiring $400 in parts at dealer list price, an independent using OE-equivalent parts might charge $240-$320 for the same quality components. That is $80-$160 in parts savings on a single repair — on top of the labor savings.

Stack the labor gap on top of the parts gap, and you start to see how a straightforward repair can cost nearly twice as much at the dealer. But the numbers vary by repair type — and some of the gaps are worse than others.

Repair-by-repair comparison

These ranges reflect typical pricing across U.S. metro and suburban markets. Your specific quote will shift by region, vehicle, and shop. The ratios, though, hold remarkably steady.

Brake job (pads + rotors, all four wheels)

  • Dealership: $800-$1,400
  • Independent: $400-$700
  • Gap: 50-100% premium at the dealer

Brakes are the textbook commodity repair. Standardized components, identical procedure regardless of who turns the wrench. OE-equivalent pads and rotors from Akebono, Centric, or StopTech meet or exceed OEM specs. There is no technical reason — none — to pay dealer pricing for a brake job on any vehicle, regardless of badge.

Timing belt + water pump

  • Dealership: $1,200-$2,000
  • Independent: $600-$1,100
  • Gap: 80-100% premium at the dealer

At 4-8 hours of labor depending on the engine, the rate gap hits hardest here. The parts — belt, tensioner, water pump, seals — come from the same OE suppliers (Gates, Aisin, Continental) whether you buy them through a dealer parts counter or a distributor. A qualified independent with experience on your engine platform delivers the same result. The dealer delivers the same result at double the price.

AC compressor replacement

  • Dealership: $1,500-$2,500
  • Independent: $800-$1,400
  • Gap: 60-80% premium at the dealer

AC work requires refrigerant recovery and recharge equipment, which most independents already own. Remanufactured compressors with full warranties run 40-50% below OEM new pricing and are standard practice in the independent market. The dealer charges a premium for a brand-new compressor you may not need.

Example: A 2021 Honda Accord owner gets a dealer quote of $1,850 for an AC compressor replacement: $950 for the OEM compressor, $200 for refrigerant and related parts, and $700 in labor (3.5 hrs at $200/hr). An independent shop quotes $1,050: $480 for a Denso remanufactured compressor (same manufacturer as OEM), $170 for refrigerant and parts, and $400 in labor (3.5 hrs at $115/hr). Same job. Same timeline. $800 difference.

When the dealer IS worth it

Dealers are not always the wrong answer. For certain categories of work, they are the only sensible one.

  • Warranty repairs: Free. Any covered repair under factory or extended warranty should go to the dealer. You pay nothing, and the manufacturer pays the dealer directly.
  • Recall and TSB repairs: Safety recalls are performed at no charge by the dealer. Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs) — known issues with manufacturer-backed repair procedures — are best handled by the dealer because they have direct access to updated procedures and may submit for goodwill coverage even outside warranty.
  • Proprietary software updates: Some repairs require reprogramming modules with manufacturer-specific software (Ford IDS, Toyota Techstream at the subscription tier, GM GDS2). While independent shops increasingly have access to these tools, certain calibration updates are dealer-exclusive.
  • Certified Pre-Owned compliance: If you are selling or trading a CPO vehicle, maintaining dealer service records preserves the CPO status and resale value. The service premium may pay for itself in resale.
The calculus: If the repair is covered under warranty, recall, or TSB — go to the dealer. If you are maintaining CPO status — go to the dealer. For everything else on an out-of-warranty vehicle, get an independent quote first and compare.

When the dealer is NOT worth it

Most routine and non-warranty repairs fall squarely in this camp — and the numbers are hard to ignore.

  • Oil changes: Dealer charges $75-$120 for conventional, $100-$170 for synthetic. Independents: $40-$70 conventional, $65-$100 synthetic. Same oil, same filter, same drain plug torque.
  • Tires: Dealer tire pricing is typically 10-20% above tire shop or online pricing, with installation fees $20-$40/tire higher. No advantage to dealer tire installation.
  • Brakes, filters, fluids, belts: Commodity maintenance with no brand-specific complexity. The independent gap is 40-60% on these services.
  • Any repair on a vehicle out of warranty: Once the warranty period ends, the dealer's primary advantage (free covered repairs) disappears. What remains is higher overhead passed to you.

Notice the pattern: every item on that list is work that requires no proprietary tools, no manufacturer software, no special access. It is wrench-turning, and paying a premium for wrench-turning buys you a nicer waiting room — nothing more.

The “dealer-only” myth

Service advisors sometimes insist that only the dealer can properly diagnose or repair modern vehicles. A decade ago, that claim had teeth. Today, independent shops run aftermarket scan tools from Autel, Launch, and Snap-on that cover 95% of diagnostic functions across all makes. The Right to Repair movement and federal regulations have forced open access to manufacturer diagnostic data that used to live behind a dealer paywall.

What to watch for: If a dealer tells you “only we can do this repair,” ask specifically why. Is it a proprietary software calibration? That may be true. Is it a brake job, a suspension repair, or an engine sensor replacement? That is not true, and the claim is designed to keep you from getting a competitive quote.

The 5% of diagnostics that remain dealer-exclusive typically involve module programming, key programming on certain brands, and specific emissions recalibrations. For the other 95%, an experienced independent with modern tooling is equally capable — at 40-60% less cost.

How to use the gap

You do not need to argue with anyone. Get the dealer estimate in writing. Get an independent estimate in writing. Set them side by side: labor rate, labor hours, parts prices, total. When the dealer is 50-80% higher for equivalent work, you have the data to make a decision — or to walk back into the dealer and ask if they will match.

Some will negotiate, especially on out-of-warranty work during slow weeks. Others will not. Either way, the choice is yours, and it is built on numbers instead of guesswork.

Have a dealer estimate you want to benchmark against independent pricing?

Run a free audit Back to all guides